
On this page
What is the difference between a Delaware C-Corp and a Delaware LLC?Which structure do investors expect when you raise money?How are a C-Corp and an LLC taxed in the United States?What does it cost to keep a Delaware C-Corp or LLC in good standing?How do you pay yourself and your investors out of each structure?Can you give employees and co-founders equity in each structure?What reporting do foreign-owned US companies have to do?The India angle: what an Indian resident founder should checkCommon mistakes Indian founders make with Delaware companiesA simple checklist for choosing between a C-Corp and an LLCImportant noteFAQsShould an Indian founder choose a Delaware C-Corp or an LLC?
If you expect to raise venture or angel investment and grant employee options, a Delaware C-Corp is generally the better fit because investment documents and stock options are built for corporations. A Delaware LLC can be simpler for a small service business without outside investors. Tax and Indian disclosure rules differ, so confirm with advisers.
- C-Corp pays 21% federal corporate tax and files Form 1120
- Delaware corporation annual report and franchise tax due 1 March
- Delaware LLC annual tax due 1 June, no annual report
What is the difference between a Delaware C-Corp and a Delaware LLC?
A Delaware C-Corp is a corporation formed under Delaware law that pays its own US federal income tax and issues shares of stock; a Delaware LLC is a limited liability company whose profits are, by default, passed through to its owners. For an Indian founder who plans to raise money from investors, that single difference in how ownership is represented (shares versus membership interests) shapes almost everything else: how you issue equity to co-founders, whether a venture fund will invest, how you give options to employees and how profits reach you personally.
Both entities give you limited liability, and both can be formed in Delaware by a non-resident without visiting the United States. If you are still weighing the two in general terms, our guide on LLC vs C-Corp for Indian founders covers the full comparison. This article focuses on the practical question that comes up most often with startups: you are building something you hope to fund, so which Delaware structure fits?
Which structure do investors expect when you raise money?
In practice, institutional investors such as venture funds and many angel groups expect to invest in a Delaware C-Corp. The reasons are mostly mechanical rather than legal. Standard investment documents, including preferred stock terms and convertible instruments such as SAFEs, are written for corporations. Funds that have tax-exempt or foreign limited partners usually prefer not to receive taxable pass-through income from an LLC. A corporation also lets the company create several classes of stock, which is how investors typically obtain liquidation preferences and other protections.
That does not mean an LLC can never raise money. Some LLCs convert to a corporation when a round is agreed, and some investors accept LLC units in small, friendly rounds. But a conversion costs time and legal fees at exactly the moment you want to close quickly, and it can create tax questions. If a priced round or a SAFE from a fund is a realistic goal within the next year or two, starting as a C-Corp is generally the simpler path. Nobody can promise how any particular investor will behave, so treat this as a general pattern, not a rule.
How are a C-Corp and an LLC taxed in the United States?
A C-Corp is a separate taxpayer. It files its own federal income tax return on Form 1120 and pays federal corporate tax at a flat 21 percent rate on its taxable income. For a calendar-year corporation the IRS instructions say the return is due by the 15th day of the 4th month after the end of the tax year, which is 15 April, and the company can request an extension using Form 7004, which generally has to be filed by the regular due date.
A single-member LLC owned by a foreign person is, by default, treated as a disregarded entity for federal income tax. The LLC itself does not pay federal income tax as a separate taxpayer, and the owner is taxed on the income according to the rules for non-residents. A multi-member LLC is treated as a partnership by default. Whether the owner owes any US tax depends mainly on whether the business income is effectively connected with a US trade or business, and that is a fact-specific question for a US tax professional. Our page on US federal tax support for foreign-owned companies explains the filings involved.
The headline lesson is that neither structure is automatically "tax-free" for an Indian founder. A C-Corp pays corporate tax first and then a second layer of tax may apply when profits are paid out to you. An LLC avoids that corporate layer in the US, but its profits may still be taxed in the United States or in India, and India has its own rules on foreign income and foreign assets.
What does it cost to keep a Delaware C-Corp or LLC in good standing?
Delaware publishes its own charges, and they differ sharply between the two entities. These are the figures the Delaware Division of Corporations states today; confirm them on the official site before you pay, because states revise fees.
- Corporation annual report. Every active Delaware corporation files an annual report and pays franchise tax by 1 March for the prior year. The state lists an annual report filing fee of USD 50 for non-exempt domestic corporations.
- Franchise tax, authorized shares method. The minimum is USD 175 for a corporation with 5,000 authorized shares or fewer, USD 250 for 5,001 to 10,000 shares, and USD 85 more for each additional 10,000 shares or part of that.
- Franchise tax, assumed par value capital method. The minimum is USD 400, calculated at USD 400 per million dollars of assumed par value capital. A corporation uses the method that gives the lower tax, and the state lists a maximum of USD 200,000.
- LLC annual tax. A Delaware LLC pays a flat annual tax, currently stated as USD 400, due by 1 June, and no annual report is required. Some older guides, including earlier material on the web, quote USD 300, so check the current amount.
- Late payment. For both entity types the state lists a USD 200 penalty plus interest of 1.5 percent per month on the tax and penalty.
The most common surprise is the franchise tax calculation. A startup that authorizes a large number of shares, for example 10 million, can receive a very high bill under the authorized shares method, but the lower assumed par value capital method usually brings it down to a modest figure. The key is to compute it properly rather than paying the first number on the notice. Our Delaware company registration service page describes how we handle this for clients.
Government fees change and service costs depend on your structure. Tell us what you need and we will send a written quote that separates government fees from our fees.
How do you pay yourself and your investors out of each structure?
With a C-Corp, money normally leaves the company as salary (if you work in the business), as dividends, or through a share sale. A dividend paid by a US corporation to a non-resident individual is subject to US withholding. The IRS states that dividends from a US source paid to a non-resident alien are subject to withholding at 30 percent or a lower treaty rate. The India-US tax treaty, in its dividends article, caps the rate at 15 percent of the gross amount where the beneficial owner is a company holding at least 10 percent of the voting stock of the payer, and at 25 percent in all other cases. A founder holding shares personally will usually fall into the second group, but whether and how the treaty rate applies depends on the paperwork you file and on your individual facts, so confirm it with a qualified adviser.
With an LLC, there is no separate dividend. The owner takes distributions, and the tax result depends on the character of the income and on whether it is effectively connected with a US business. Many Indian founders who run a service business from India through a US LLC find that the LLC is simple to administer. Founders building a fundable product company often find the corporation better suited, even though the two layers of tax are a real cost.
Can you give employees and co-founders equity in each structure?
This is where the C-Corp usually wins for startups. A corporation can issue common stock to founders, subject to vesting, and set up an option pool for employees. Stock options are well understood by lawyers, accountants and candidates, and a corporation can grant them without complex tax allocations. An LLC can offer profits interests or membership units, but these instruments are harder to explain and can create tax filings for each holder. If you expect to hire a team and offer meaningful equity, the corporation reduces friction.
US rules also reward certain corporate stock. Section 1202 of the Internal Revenue Code lets some holders of qualified small business stock exclude part or all of their gain on sale, subject to conditions. The IRS has described the rules as tiered by how long the stock is held, with up to 100 percent of the gain excludable at five years or more and a higher per-issuer cap of 15 million dollars for newly issued stock. The conditions are detailed, covering the type of business, the size of the company's assets and who holds the stock, and the benefit applies only to US tax. Whether a non-resident Indian founder benefits, and how India treats the same gain, needs individual advice. Do not choose a structure on the strength of this alone, but it is one reason investors and lawyers favour C-Corps.
What reporting do foreign-owned US companies have to do?
Both structures have information reporting that is easy to miss. A US corporation that is 25 percent foreign-owned, and certain foreign-owned disregarded entities, must report specified transactions with related parties on Form 5472. The IRS lists a penalty of USD 25,000 for each failure to file a complete and correct return by the due date, with continuing penalties if it is not filed within 90 days of an IRS notice and no maximum amount. Many founders only learn about the form after the company has been dormant for a year, so it is worth building into your calendar from the first day. We explain the filing in detail on our Form 5472 and pro forma 1120 page and in our article on the USD 25,000 Form 5472 penalty.
A C-Corp also needs corporate formalities that an LLC can sometimes relax: bylaws, a board, officers, stock ledgers and minutes. These are not hard, but they are real tasks, and investors will ask to see them during due diligence.
The India angle: what an Indian resident founder should check
Forming a US company is only half the picture for an Indian resident. Putting money into a foreign company is generally an overseas investment under India's foreign exchange rules, and individuals normally send funds under the Liberalised Remittance Scheme within the limits and permitted purposes set by the Reserve Bank of India. The rules on holding shares in a foreign company, on reporting the investment and on annual disclosure have been revised in recent years, and they differ depending on whether you hold shares in a corporation or an interest in an LLC. Foreign assets and interests also need to be disclosed in your Indian income tax return, including in Schedule FA, whether or not the company makes a profit.
India may also tax your share of income or any dividend you receive, and it may give credit for US tax paid depending on the treaty and your filings. Because the answer depends on your residential status and facts, speak to an Indian chartered accountant before you remit funds. Our guide for Indians registering a company abroad sets out the issues to raise with them.
Common mistakes Indian founders make with Delaware companies
- Choosing an LLC and then raising money. Founders form an LLC for simplicity, then discover that the first investor wants a corporation and must pay for a conversion.
- Authorizing too many shares without checking franchise tax. The authorized shares method can produce an alarming bill; the alternative method is usually far lower.
- Ignoring Form 5472. Related-party transactions, including the founder's own capital contributions, must be reported even if the company earns nothing.
- Skipping founder vesting. Investors usually ask for founder stock to vest over time, and doing it at formation is cleaner than retrofitting it.
- Mixing personal and company money. This weakens liability protection and creates reporting problems. Our guide on opening a US business bank account from India explains how to set up a clean account.
- Assuming the registered agent handles compliance. A registered agent receives legal mail; it does not file your annual report or tax returns for you.
- Forgetting Indian disclosure. Not reporting the foreign company and its funding in India can cause serious problems later.
A simple checklist for choosing between a C-Corp and an LLC
- Do you expect outside equity investment within two years? If yes, lean towards a Delaware C-Corp.
- Will you grant equity or options to employees or advisers? If yes, a corporation is usually easier.
- Do you plan to take profits out yearly? If you plan to pay yourself regularly from earnings, compare the combined US and Indian tax result of each structure with an adviser.
- Is the business mainly a service or consulting business you run alone? An LLC may be lighter to maintain, but check the tax result in both countries.
- Can you keep up with the filings? Make a calendar for Delaware (1 March for corporations, 1 June for LLCs), IRS returns, Form 5472 where it applies and Indian disclosures.
- Have you chosen the state deliberately? Delaware is the usual choice for companies raising money, and our comparison of Delaware, Wyoming and New Mexico explains when another state is enough.
The best answer depends on your plan, not on a rule that fits everyone. If you want a second opinion on structure (our LLC vs C-Corp guide is a good companion read), formation steps and the post-formation checklist, you can start with our US company registration for Indian founders page, or use the consultation form on this page and our team will walk through your situation with you.
For the underlying rules, use the official sources directly: the Delaware Division of Corporations for state fees and filings and the Internal Revenue Service for federal tax and information-return rules.
Important note
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules, fees and thresholds change; confirm current requirements with the relevant authority or a qualified adviser. Global BizTalk is a business-services company, not a law firm or CPA firm.